My 10 Favorite Films of 2024

 2024 ended with a total of 96 movies reviewed and with that here are my 10 favorite films of the year.  

This year was filled with plenty of unexpected surprises especially in my favorite genre, horror, which is always welcome.  

As always, I’ll add the disclaimer that these are my personal favorites of the year which include a handful of admittedly flawed films that I enjoyed, nonetheless.

Without further ado here is my list presented in no particular order.

Robert Eggers’ Nosferatu is a gothic marvel of the macabre that leaves an indelible impression.  The film shows a director on a steady upward trajectory as he gains even more confidence in his craft.  Lily-Rose Depp delivers one of her best performances here while Willem Dafoe steals every scene, he’s in.  

Nosferatu Review

Heretic is one of those films that came out of seemingly nowhere to deliver a heady piece of horror.  It doesn’t manage to stick the landing as it feels the need to fall back on standard horror tropes, but Hugh Grant’s inspired turn makes it more than worthwhile.   

Heretic Review

Coralie Fargeat’s The Substance not so subtle critique of unattainable standards in Hollywood uses its aggressive visuals and stellar performances from Demi Moore and Margaret Qualley to deliver a singular experience.  The back end turns into something more akin to 1989’s Society which may not be for everyone, but you must appreciate the sheer guts to go full bore into the metaphor.

The Substance Review

The original Smile was decent at best for my taste, so the sequel didn’t rank highly on list of anticipated films.  Parker Finn’s sequel delivered well above expectations with its more meticulous decent into madness led by a star making turn from Naomi Scott as a pop star fraying at the seams.  

Smile 2 Review

The Wild Robot is a deceptively simple mix of Wall-E and The Iron Giant but that doesn’t keep it from being any less impactful.  Its lush visuals paired with heartfelt voicework by an all-star cast led by Lupita Nyong'o make it a poignant emotional journey.

The Wild Robot Review

As a child of the 80’s, Transformers will always hold a special place in my heart and the news of a new animated film until an underwhelming trailer had my expectations set low.  Surprisingly, this reimagining was thoughtful and gave the central bots well defined characteristics and motivations.   The vibrant animation and strong voicework resulted in one of the best Transformers movies since the original animated film.  

Transformers One Review

Strange Darling is a fun jigsaw puzzle of a movie that takes advantage of its nonlinear set up to keep the audience off kilter until the central reveal.  It’s not a new approach but J.T. Mollner’s style is refreshingly energetic throughout his efficiently paced thriller.  Willa Fitzgerald and Kyle Gallner deliver excellent performances as predator and prey.  

Strange Darling Review

2024 was filled with plenty of pleasant surprises but nothing quite as unexpected as the Indian import, Kill.  What starts as a cheesy melodrama quickly turns into an ultra-violent story of survival confined almost entirely to a moving train that feels like a spiritual successor to the 2011 Indonesian import The Raid.

Kill Review

The First Omen could have come and gone as another cash grab pilfering from an established IP.   Arkasha Stevenson could have delivered a paint by the numbers prequel and collected an easy paycheck however what she actually delivered was far more refined and layered.  Nell Tiger Free performance is sure to earn cult status in the coming years and left me anxious for her next big screen role.  

The First Omen Review

All the set-up work done in Denis Villeneuve’s first Dune paid off in spades with the second entry which brought together the story to deliver an epic sci-fi drama.  Massive on multiple levels but the film’s real highlight is that we finally get more involved emotionally with the central characters’ journey, ambitions and betrayal.   

Dune 2 Review

Honorable Mentions

Justin Kurzel's latest, The Order, came an went with little fanfare even though it sported a strong cast and engaging true crime tale.  Jude Law, Nicholas Hoult and Tye Sheridan all deliver strong work in this taut thriller that deserved more attention than it received.  

The Order Review

Fede Álvarez managed to bring back the look and feel of the first two Alien films with this impressive refresh.  Sure, it shoehorns call backs to those film throughout with some landing better than others but that doesn't keep it from being an effective bit of cinematic comfort food.

Alien Romulus Review

The Ministry of Ungentlemanly Warfare is another one of those film's that came and went with little fanfare even though it has a name director and cast.  Guy Ritchie's WW2 is a fun ensemble piece that's fun and thrilling for the majority of its runtime plus its always great to see Henry Cavill having fun onscreen.  

The Ministry of Ungentlemanly Warfare Review

Late Night with The Devil is one of those horror gems that pops up from time to time as it recreates the look and feel of the 70's talk show with an sinister underpinning.  It doesn't seem to know how to bring it all together at the end but that doesn't keep it from being an impressive bit of filmmaking powered by a great performance from David Dastmalchian.

Late Night with The Devil Review

Rose Glass' sophomore film shows a noticeable level of growth and confidence from her impressive debut film, Saint Maude.  This love story takes us through a series twisted and hallucinatory sequences that keep you off balance throughout.  Kristen Stewart and Katy M. O'Brian make for hell of onscreen couple with their energy popping offscreen.  Ed Harris steals every scene he's in while wearing one of the more impressive wigs in recent history.

Love Lies Bleeding Review

MOVIE REVIEW: THE RETURN

 

After 20 years away, Odysseus washes up on the shores of Ithaca, haggard and unrecognizable. The king finds much has changed since he left to fight in the Trojan War. His beloved wife, Penelope, is a prisoner in her own home and hounded to choose a new husband. Their son faces death at the hands of suitors who see him as an obstacle in their pursuit of Penelope and the kingdom. Odysseus is no longer the mighty warrior his people remember, but he must face his past to save his family.

Director: Uberto Pasolini

Cast: Ralph Fiennes, Juliette Binoche, Charlie Plummer, Marwan Kenzari, Claudio Santamaria, Tom Rhys Harries, Ángela Molina

Release Date: December 6, 2024

Genre: History

Rated R for violence, some sexual content, graphic nudity and language.

Runtime: 1h 56m

Review:

Uberto Pasolini's ultra grounded take on the back half of The Odyssey is powered by a pair of stellar performances from its central duo of Ralph Fiennes and Juliette Binoche.  Pasolini strips away all the Greek gods from the original text, focusing more on the human toll taken by the hero's search for glory.  This naturalistic take on the material focuses more on the mental state of central characters of Odysseus, Penelope and Telemachus as opposed to action or intrigue.  It makes for a film that's decidedly light on frills with Pasolini setting up scenes for performers to shine.  Ralph Fiennes carrying an emaciated and battered frame delivers a powerful but understated performance as an Odysseus haunted by the specter of war and the choices that led him there.  Fiennes has an ability to communicate volumes worth of emotional information with a single look or mannerism.  It’s not a particularly dialogue heavy role but he proves more than capable of giving the audience a real sense of the death and remorse his character has experienced during his long journey home.  Juliette Binoche is equally impressive as the ever-dutiful Penelope whom she imbues with quiet intensity and strength.   When Binoche and Fiennes finally share the screen, she delivers an emotionally powerful monologue that she imbues with a Shakespearean sensibility.  It serves as one of the most powerful moments in the film and a solid payoff for investing its occasionally ponderous pacing.  Fiennes and Binoche are thoroughly engaging every time they are onscreen, unfortunately the supporting cast never manages to match their work.  Charlie Plummer's Telemachus lacks the depth or nuance of his onscreen parents which gives the character more of bratty quality that feels off.  Marwan Kenzari's Antinous is more intriguing, but he's never given enough screentime to flesh out his character and singular focus on becoming Penelope's new husband.  It’s a shame because it would have given the story an interesting angle from one of the suitors who isn't an outright barbarian.  It’s the kind of thing that would have added to the effectiveness of the film but stumbles aside The Return succeeds on the power of its two stars.  

B

MOVIE REVIEW: THE DAMNED

 

A 19th-century widow is forced to make an impossible choice during a cruel winter when a ship sinks off the coast, risking what's left of the village's dwindling supplies.

Director: Thordur Palsson

Cast: Odessa Young, Joe Cole, Lewis Gribben, Siobhan Finneran, Francis Magee, Rory McCann, Turlough Convery, Mícheál Óg Lane, Andrean Sigurgeirsson

US Release Date: January 3, 2025/UK  Release Date January 10, 2025

Genre: Drama, Horror, Mystery

Rated R for bloody violent content, suicide and some language.

Runtime: 1h 29m

Review:

The Damned, Thordur Palsson's feature debut, is an eerie, atmospheric slow burn of a creeper which takes full advantage of its isolated setting and stellar performances.  Palsson film moves at a methodical pace which sets up the characters and their isolated, claustrophobic setting with little fluff or frills.  Eli Arenson’s cinematography is beautifully bleak and foreboding throughout making the icy mountains and frigid coastline characters unto themselves.  The film's pacing may not be for everyone since it moves at a glacial pace with only a handful of increasingly repetitive jump scares breaking it up.  Those looking for cheap thrills will likely be left wanting as this leans closer to Robert Eggers' The Witch as opposed to something like John Carpenter's The Thing even though it still shares aspects of both.  This film is much more a meditation on grief and guilt, themes other "elevated" horror films have covered in the past.  As such, there isn't a ton of new ground to explore but the cast led by an excellent turn from Odessa Young ruminates those themes compelling and engaging.  Young's understated performance carries the film, as she manages to convey the character's exterior steadfastness while she’s slowly fraying at the corners underneath.  Her large expressive eyes deliver a boatload of emotional information as the situation becomes increasingly fraught and tenuous.  It’s a fascinating performance that would have been served better if her character had been better fleshed out in the film's opening since we're given very little background information about her or her companions.  The supporting characters aren't written with much depth, but the entire supporting cast delivers authentic turns in each role giving the group a weathered chemistry that makes you believe they've all lived together for years.  Rory McCann, of Game of Thrones fame, is set up to be a major player early on but for some reason he's taken off the screen relatively early on to the film's detriment.  It’s an odd choice since his presence would have added so much more to the film, especially as it moves into its end game.  Up to that point the story walked a steady tightrope between real and imagined horrors that plague our increasingly dwindling group.  A bit more ambiguity would have helped The Damned be a more effective film but as an opening salvo for his career Thordur Palsson still manages to leave a strong impression.

B-

MOVIE REVIEW: BABYGIRL

 

A high-powered CEO puts her career and family on the line when she begins a torrid affair with a much younger intern.

Director: Halina Reijn

Cast: Nicole Kidman, Harris Dickinson, Sophie Wilde, Antonio Banderas

Release Date: December 25, 2024

Genre: Crime, Drama, Mystery, Thriller

Rated R for strong sexual content, nudity and language.

Runtime: 1h 54m

Review:

Babygirl plays like a gender-swapped version of 2002's Secretary and when it works it pulsates off the screen, but it struggles to maintain that energy despite a stellar turn from Nicole Kidman.  Writer/Director Halina Reijn has plenty on her mind as she presents a series of tantalizing themes over the course of her film.  Sexual desire, normalcy, power dynamics and age all bounce around the edges of the screen as we follow the torrid affair with her intern played by Harris Dickinson.  Kidman's performance is a study in layers as she gives the audiences glimpses of strength, intelligence, repression and shame that are all bottled up in her character.  She's consistently the most interesting performer onscreen as she crafts this fully formed character that feels like a living breathing person along with all her complications.  Her performance carries the film but the central relationship between her and the intern is a bit choppier due to a variety of reasons.  Harris Dickinson and Kidman just don't share the kind of electric chemistry together that would make their affair believable.  His character is terribly underwritten with the audience never being presented because he's so attractive to Romy.  We're told at various points that he is intelligent but never shown anything outside of the most generic sort of blackmail.  He's never portrayed with the sort of charisma or tact that he would be able to engage and enchant in the way we're led to believe on screen.  It doesn't help that he looks like any random, faceless guy you'd see on a subway or train and never give a second thought about.  The film's kinkier moments really play more like softcore Cinemax than anything else albeit with Kidman going for broke with each scene.  Antonio Banderas has a small supporting role as Kidman's husband, and he's given an impressive scene in the final act that reminds you how powerful of a performer he can be.  The film would have been well served had it given him a bit more screentime and fleshed out his character more but like most of the themes that Reijn throws onscreen such as an undercurrent about the monotony and automation of our everyday lives are never explored in any sort of meaningful way.  There's plenty left unexplored throughout which is shame because Reijn does deliver a series of energetic moments topped by a sequence in a dance club that just reverberates off the screen.  These sorts of moments highlight surges of energy in Babygirl which highlight how much more effective the film would have been if it had something substantial to say about itself.  

B-

MOVIE REVIEW: NOSFERATU

 

In the 1830s, estate agent Thomas Hutter travels to Transylvania for a fateful meeting with Count Orlok, a prospective client. In his absence, Hutter's new bride, Ellen, is left under the care of their friends, Friedrich and Anna Harding. Plagued by horrific visions and an increasing sense of dread, Ellen soon encounters an evil force that's far beyond her control.

Director: Robert Eggers

Cast: Bill Skarsgård, Nicholas Hoult, Lily-Rose Depp, Aaron Taylor-Johnson, Emma Corrin, Ralph Ineson, Simon McBurney, Willem Dafoe

Release Date: December 25, 2024

Genre: Fantasy, Horror, Mystery

Rated R for bloody violent content, graphic nudity and some sexual content.

Runtime: 2h 12m

Review:

Robert Eggers' remake of 1922's Nosferatu doesn't add much to the general story but it's a visual marvel of the macabre that delivers a wonderfully opulent series of gothic imaginary that's sure to leave an impression.  Eggers's talents are perfectly suited for the subject matter and every shot reflects his deep affect and love of the material.  He manages to create an impressive sense of dread and foreboding even though the story doesn't offer up much in the way of surprises.  He and his cinematographer, Jarin Blaschke, meticulously frame shots with an incredible level of care which results in a steady stream of memorable shots with the blue toned monochromatic night shots being particularly effective.  The film moves at Eggers' usual pace but a series of well-placed shocks pepper the film with those moments injecting the screen with chaotic energy.  Lily-Rose Depp delivers stellar work in some of these moments with a physical performance that's filled with wild fits of manic gyrations that echo moments from The Exorcist more than anything else.  She maintains a detached, almost trance-like stare during the film's quieter portions with exasperated moments of lucidity allowing her to display a full range of emotions.  Depp's turn is fascinating from start to finish but it’s one of those aspects that you'd wish Eggers had expanded on since there's plenty of fertile ground to explore outside of the repressed sexuality of the original.  The supporting cast is made up on a solid group of performers but similarly the script doesn't ask a lot of them outside of looking terrified, like Hoult, while he's being cuckold or borderline crazed like Willem Dafoe which is about par for the course for him.  Aaron Taylor-Johnson looks the part but some of his lines come off as unintentionally comical partly due to his handle bar mustache.  Emma Corrin is wasted for the most part as she's given very little to do outside of stand around and ask how Depp's Ella is doing and reassure her she's not a burden.  Bill Skarsgård is tasked with portraying Count Orlok which he does with a heavy Eastern European accent in between wheezes.  His portrayal paired with the creature's makeup makes for a far more decrepit depiction of the monster with any sense of suave sexuality from other integrations stripped away to something more primal.  The character's full features are slowly revealed throughout before being shown in its full glory in the final act as we get the full scope of his massive, rotting corpse.  In the end, Nosferatu may prove to be one of Robert Eggers more accessible film for those looking for high end frights and fitting tribute to one of the original horror films.  

A-

MOVIE REVIEW: A COMPLETE UNKNOWN

 

In the early 1960s, 19-year-old Bob Dylan arrives in New York with his guitar and revolutionary talent, destined to change the course of American music. Forming his most intimate relationships during his rise to fame, he grows restless with the folk movement, making a controversial choice that reverberates worldwide.

Director: James Mangold

Cast: Timothée Chalamet, Edward Norton, Elle Fanning, Monica Barbaro, Boyd Holbrook, Dan Fogler, Norbert Leo Butz, Scoot McNairy

Release Date: December 25, 2024

Genre: Biography, Drama, Music

Rated R for language.

Runtime: 2h 20m

Review:

A Complete Unknown serves as a time capsule that focuses on four formative years of Bob Dylan's career in the 60s that places you firmly in the moment although it never gives you any insight into his headspace.  James Mangold's second foray into musical biopics finds the director in his wheelhouse as he recreates the look and feel of the early 60's folk music scene that Dylan walks into.  He directs the performances with ease allowing the performers and music to take center stage while avoiding some of the more obvious pitfalls and tropes that Walk The Line fell into.  There aren't nearly as many contrived moments were moments immediately lead into the creation of signature songs although there is still of relationship melodrama which just seems baked into these kind of stories.  As a result, the film has a more naturalistic and organic feel to it as we follow Dylan's rise from obscurity to mega stardom.  Interlaced into his personal journey are newsclips woven into the background about the major political and cultural events occurring during these nascent years of his career.  We assume these moments lead to the creation of some of Dylan's most famous songs but the film never overtly connects the two.  This is partly due to the fact that we are kept at arms length from Dylan's internal motivations as the audience is given very few glimpses into his psyche outside of being a mysterious, ambitious iconoclast.  There's painfully little insight provided throughout the film's runtime perhaps by design as we get little more than he's a genius but self centered jerk.  The supporting characters don't fare much better as we're given only the most basic information about everyone we meet.  Its a testament to the cast that they're performances are as engaging and effective as they are given the script's shortcomings. Timothée Chalamet leads the film by dissolving into Bob Dylan's mannerism and vocal inflections to deliver a truly impressive bit of cinematic mimicry.  Where his performance truly shines is during the musical portions of the film as Chalamet sings and plays Dylan's songs rarely missing a bit along the way.  Its an impressive fully formed performance that goes the extra step above the usual imitation game although you wish the script had given him a bit more meat to work with.  Edward Norton's Pete Seeger proves to be more fleshed out as the folk stalwart that is desperately hoping to fight back the electrical musical revolution.  It's a measured and thoughtful turn that humanizes the character by giving him varying levels of depth.  Elle Fanning and Monica Barbaro deliver strong performances as parts of the central love triangle although neither is given much depth on their own and an on stage moment between Dylan and Baez that feels lifted from Mangold's own Walk The Line comes off as overkill. Boyd Holbrook is solid in spots as Johnny Cash while we are left wishing Scoot McNairy had been given a bit more to do as Woody Guthrie.  A Complete Unknown lives up to its name as it gives the audience just enough about the people we are watching while never letting us truly understand them in any meaningful way.  

B+